Electric scooters offer convenience and speed, ideal for urban commutes, while ordinary scooters are more budget-friendly and exercise-inducing.
A Performance Comparison
Speed and Acceleration.
Electric scooters – when compared to conventional scooters – are prized for speed and acceleration in particular, and many electric scooter models reach 15-20 mph, with a typical conventional scooter peaking by the rider’s amount of effort, generally topped off at 10 mph. Electric scooters’ motors hover around 250 to 500 watts, yielding the very quick acceleration that renders them so suitable for city environments filled with stop and go traffic. The immediate torque that these motors provide means that the throttle responds almost instantaneously after the rider pulls it, ensuring that scooter excels in the extremely low-speed agility that comes with starting from a standstill.
Range and Battery Life for Electric Scooters.
The range of electric scooters is a similarly key aspect of their performance, and most electric scooter models have a battery life that provides them with a 10-40 mile range that varies depending on the scooter’s battery’s capacity, measured in watt-hours (Wh). Though not featured by inexpensive electric scooters, the higher-end scooters can be had with batteries as large as 250 Wh to over 500 Wh, just as you had said, which could provide ranges of 40 miles or more, making these electric scooters practically full-fledged and cheap gasoline cars. The life of these batteries is also worthy of note, since they can often last for 500-1000 charge cycles without significant capacity depreciation, which often equates to a several years of daily use.
Maneuverability and Control.
One area in which a conventional scooter excels is in maneuverability, due to its lightness and simplicity, providing excellent turning and navigation through very tight spaces and crowded areas and thanks to of a ebike’s lack of such a bulky motor and battery makes them well-suited for mildly imprecise movements and very short distances. The electric scooters’ added weight is generally offset by modern features such as electronic braking systems, wide tires for better stability, and in many cases, front and rear suspension that is indispensible for control and comfort on anything less than perfect road surfaces, even contributing to a larger margin of safety than conventional scooters, especially in regards to the higher speeds and longer distances that a scooter is capable of.
Cost Analysis
Initial Purchase Price
Electric scooters generally come with a higher initial purchase price than ordinary models due to their higher technological content, especially the battery. A decent scooter may sell for $300 to $1,000, with high-end models going higher still. Ordinary scooters, on the other hand, can sell for as little as $50, with higher-end models at $200 or more. Therefore initial purchase price can be a very important factor where initial scooter usage is uncertain or for one on a tight budget.
Maintenance and Repair Costs
Electric scooters usually have much higher upkeep costs than the ordinary versions. The systems are more complex – a battery, electric motor, and an electronic control unit (ECU). The biggest ticket item by far is the replacement of the battery. Lithium-ion batteries have a life of 2 to 4 years. They sell for $100 to $300 or so. Ordinary scooter systems rely much more on physical components – wheels, bearings, speedometers, brakes, etc. – and are much cheaper to keep up. Replacements are common and the cost low.
Operating Costs: Electricity vs. Physical Effort
The electric scooter cost is the cost of the battery’s electricity charge. An average scooter, 250Wh battery capacity, say, costs $0.03 to charge it if electricity sells for $0.13 per kWh. The ordinary scooter has no direct financial cost, although in terms of physical effort and time, it can be quite expensive, especially over longer distances. The convenience and lack of physical effort and time are the trade-off for the minor amount of electricity expenses of an electric model.
Taking all these costs together is less important than understanding it means that, operationally, one is really more expensive than the other. Initially, the costs are very different, as are the continued expenses; but, in either case, it is possible significant negatives or advantages are lost in the details to what an individual will experience depending on their needs or per-usage financial constraints.
Safety Features and Considerations
Built-in Safety Features: Electric vs. Ordinary Scooters
Advanced safety features largely set electric scooters apart from ordinary scooters. Scooters powered by electric motors often include such things as front and rear lights, electronic braking systems, and sometimes turn signals. Most on-road and folding electric scooters also include a bright headlight and a rear light for increased visibility, making them a good option for the often dimly lit urban rider. This is in stark contrast to ordinary scooters, which are propelled entirely by foot power and feature no lighting components on most models, making them much less visible — particularly in low-light situations.
Visibility and Night Riding
This visibility is a key safety consideration and becomes even more critical when riding at night. The majority of electric scooters feature an integrated lighting system that makes them increasingly visible to other vehicles, pedestrians, and other riders. To further expedite this, reflective materials can be added to the deck, handlebars, and front and rear fenders of most models. Using reflective clothing on any scooter is suggested for safer riding, as is attaching a white light to the front and a red light to the rear of the scooter when venturing through poorly lit areas on ordinary scooters.
Recommendations for Safe Scooter Use
Of course, the most fundamental safety recommendation for all scooter riders is to wear a helmet. The risk of head injury in the event of an accident is reduced significantly by wearing a helmet, as it is for any active sport. For an additional level of protection, knee and elbow pads can also be worn. On any scooter, it is essential to learn and obey local traffic laws in order to share roads and pathways safely with other vehicles and pedestrians. It’s also recommended to maintain the scooter’s battery and mechanical systems on electric scooters, to help guard against a malfunction than can result in a dangerous situation. Regularly checking tire pressure, ensuring that brakes work properly, and confirming that the lights on the scooter are functioning correctly all go a long way in achieving a safe and secure riding experience.
